PART I – MY ARGUMENT
US Regime Change In Venezuela Will Lower Gold Prices
1. Core Thesis
The US-led regime change in Venezuela will reduce geopolitical risk and lower the price of gold.
It signals that America accepts a multipolar world and is now prioritising regional dominance over global hegemony.
2. A Changed International Order
The erosion of the US-led rules-based order is no longer controversial.
It is broadly understood, priced in, and increasingly accepted ( at least in the West!).
As a result:
- Violations of old rules no longer shock markets
- Moral arguments matter less than outcomes
- Geopolitical risk premia are structurally lower than in the past
Rules-based order: the post-1945 US-led system of institutions, norms, and enforcement
3. Energy Market Effects
The regime change in Venezuela will likely:
- Stabilise or lower global oil prices
- Reduce US dependence on Middle Eastern supply
- Diminish Iran’s leverage over the Strait of Hormuz
This:
- Suppresses inflation expectations
- Reduces energy-driven volatility
- Lowers the need for inflation hedges
All of this is negative for gold.
Inflation expectations: markets’ forward view of future price stability
4. Acceptance Of Multipolarity And Spheres Of Influence
The Venezuela move can be read as explicit acceptance of a multipolar world organised into regions.
Americas
- Strengthens US dominance in its backyard
- Weakens Canadian bargaining power esp on oil
- Intimidates South American regimes into compliance
Europe
- Implies US willingness to concede Ukraine to Russia
- Forces Europe to manage its own security problems
Asia
- Suggests acceptance that Taiwan ultimately belongs to China
Middle East
- Lowers the threshold for action against Iran
- Shifts justification from nuclear capability to ballistic missile threats
- Aligns US posture more closely with Israeli security priorities
This is less idealistic, but clearer and more stable.
5. Economic Benefits
The economic consequences include:
- Significant gains for US oil companies
- Lower and more stable energy prices
- Contained inflation pressures
Lower inflation and lower volatility weaken the strategic case for gold.
6. Conclusion – My View On Gold
Acceptance of multipolarity and defined spheres of influence will reduce global tensions rather than raise them.
The logical chain is straightforward:
Multipolar acceptance → lower global tensions → reduced geopolitical risk premium → lower gold prices
PART II – AI RESPONSE AND MARKET ASSESSMENT
I put this argument to AI and this is its response.
How Markets Would Likely Price This Scenario
7. Framing The Thesis Correctly
Your argument is internally consistent.
The key question is not morality, but market pricing.
Your core claims are:
- The rules-based order is already dead in practice
- Markets have adjusted psychologically
- The US is pivoting to hemispheric dominance
- Oil risk, inflation risk, geopolitical risk mean tail risks decline
If markets accept this framing, gold’s geopolitical premium weakens.
Multipolarity: a world with several dominant power centres rather than one hegemon
8. Oil Prices And Inflation Expectations
Your strongest point concerns oil.
If effective control over Venezuelan supply:
- Lowers marginal oil prices
- Reduces US exposure to Middle Eastern shocks
- Neutralises Iranian choke-point leverage
Then:
- Inflation expectations fall
- Real yields stabilise or rise
- Gold loses a key macro tailwind
Historically, gold underperforms when energy is abundant and inflation risk is falling.
Real yields: interest rates adjusted for inflation
9. Acceptance Of Spheres Of Influence
This is a subtle but powerful argument.
Markets prefer:
- Clear red lines
- Fewer moral crusades
- Lower miscalculation risk
If the US tacitly accepts:
- Russia in Ukraine
- China in Taiwan
- Israeli-led escalation against Iran
Then global risk premia can compress rather than expand.
This would:
- Reduce volatility
- Lower hedge demand
- Cap gold’s upside
10. The Americas As A Fortress Bloc
Hemispheric consolidation implies:
- Stronger US negotiating leverage
- Disciplined South American regimes
- Secured energy, food, and logistics chains
From a capital markets perspective:
- Tail risks decline
- The dollar zone strengthens
- US terms of trade improve
All of these are headwinds for gold.
Terms of trade: the relationship between export and import prices affecting national income
11. Vulnerabilities In The Argument
There are two pressure points.
Trust Versus Fear
Even in a multipolar world:
- Central banks fear confiscation risk
- Corporates fear sanctions unpredictability
- States fear precedent more than theory
Modern gold demand is often about insurance against coercion, not war.
Execution Risk
Markets will price:
- Legal challenges
- Sabotage and disruption
- Guerrilla instability
- Domestic political backlash in the US
If execution looks messy, gold quickly regains relevance.
12. Likely Gold Outcome
Putting it together:
- Any initial gold spike would likely be modest and short-lived
- Oil stabilisation is a meaningful gold headwind
- Inflation suppression is gold-negative
- The geopolitical risk premium compresses
Net result:
- Gold trades sideways to lower
- Volatility declines after adjustment
- The long-term bull case pauses but does not reverse
This is not a collapse scenario for gold.
It is a regime in which gold underperforms cash, energy equities, and US real assets.
13. Strategic Bottom Line
If markets believe the US is brutally pragmatic and competent, gold loses urgency.
If they believe it is brutal but clumsy, gold regains its status as chief alternative to the dollar.
14. Glossary Of Key Terms
Safe haven: an asset expected to hold value during uncertainty
Real yields: interest rates minus inflation
Geopolitical risk premium: extra return demanded for political uncertainty
Reserve asset: an asset held by central banks for stability
References
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Keep it clean, keep it lean